| Name | Sport | Inducted |
| Art Asbury | Motorsports | 1990 |
| Jack Bionda | Lacrosse/Hockey | 1990 |
| Gail Cummings | Lacrosse | 1990 |
| Hattie Briggs | Skating | 1991 |
| Ernest “Tan” Housser | Lacrosse | 1991 |
| Ken Ward | Hockey | 1991 |
| Ivan Thompson | Lacrosse | 1992 |
| Scott Hutcheson | Skiing | 1993 |
| Barry Webb | Motorsports | 1993 |
| Pat Brothers | Baseball/Curling | 1994 |
| David Arnold | Gymnastics | 1996 |
| John Clayton | 1996 | |
| Tom Conlin | Lacrosse/Hockey | 1996 |
| Andy Longpre | Wrestling | 1996 |
| Abbot Conway | Track & Field | 1997 |
| Evan Jenkins | Curling | 1997 |
| Gordon Leverton | Curling | 1997 |
| Brian Thompson | Lacrosse | 1997 |
| Jim Higgs | Lacrosse/Hockey | 1998 |
| George Snowden | Lacrosse | 1998 |
| Gordon Middleton | Football/Curling | 2001 |
| Tiffany Finley-Tsuyuki | Wakeboarding | 2013 |
| Paul Kennedy | Golf | 2013 |
| Andy Mattice | Waterskiing | 2013 |
| Don McCormick | Triathlon | 2013 |
| Jim Meredith | Lacrosse | 2013 |
| Shannon Meunier | Figure Skating | 2013 |
| Ethan Moreau | Hockey | 2013 |
| Don Stinson | Lacrosse | 2013 |
| Bob Wild | Triathlon | 2013 |
| Dara Howell | Ski Slopestyle | 2014 |
| Dan Roycroft | Cross-Country Skiing | 2014 |
| Murray Ruby | Fastball | 2014 |
| Stan Rimmington | Fastball | 2015 |
| Larry Ireland | Lacrosse/Hockey | 2017 |
| Ken Thompson | Lacrosse/Hockey | 2017 |
| Linda Rowe | Badminton/Track | 2018 |
| George “Twinkletoes” Selkirk | Baseball | 2018 |
| Gary Slatter | Golf | 2021 (2022) |
| Jeff Allen | Judo | 2021 (2022) |
| Linda Rosbottom | Baseball | 2023 |
| Colin Boucher | Lacrosse | 2023 |
| Rick Boucher | Lacrosse | 2023 |
| Joanne Bennett | Hockey | 2023 |
| Dan Shirtliff | Motorsports | 2024 |
| Bob Pepplar | Hockey/Lacrosse | 2024 |
| Brad Rhiness | Hockey | 2025 |
| Barry Brear | Lacrosse | 2025 |